Olympus-OM
[Top] [All Lists]

[OM] Alien 35-105? [was Oily 300/4.5. Suggestions?]

Subject: [OM] Alien 35-105? [was Oily 300/4.5. Suggestions?]
From: Moose <olymoose@xxxxxxxxx>
Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 13:40:28 -0700
John Hermanson wrote:
> At least the plate has 3 screws holding it all together when you drop it back 
> in.  That is what tipped me off that the 35-105 zoom is definitely not 
> Olympus built.  The only screws holding all the blade parts in are 
> the 3-4 screws that hold the blade assembly into the barrel. You have to ...
>   

I'm certainly in no position to argue with your expertise. I did make a 
modest effort (i.e. no tear-downs) to check the persistent rumor that it 
was a version of the similar spec Tokina. Here's my list of comparison 
points:

------------------------------------------------------------------
"I can see where someone could at a casual look think they might be the 
same underneath. They are very similar in size, weight and overall 
appearance except for very different rubber focus/zoom ring covers. On 
closer inspection, I note the following:

1.  Coating reflections are different colors, indicating different 
coating design/technology, and size/depths, indicating different 
internal element shape/configuration.

2.  Front mounting of the front element of the zooming group is slightly 
different.

3.  The Zuiko focusing helicoid takes considerably less rotation of the 
focus/zoom ring to get to its
minimum of 1.5m and than the Tokina takes to go to its minimum of 1.6m

4.  Zoom ring travel from 35-105mm is 20.8mm on the Zuik and 20.6mm on 
the Tokina.

5.  Although the close focus mechanism uses the same principle of acting 
as an extension tube, the ring moves in opposite directions on the 2 
lenses, locks into CU position on the Zuiko, but not on the Tokina and 
has a different extension length, 6.6mm on the Zuiko and 8.3mm on the 
Tokina.

6.  Both have 6 blade diaphrams that point their fingers clockwise, but 
they are mounted opposite ways, with the fingers on the Zuiko toward the 
front and the Tokina to the back. The Zuiko hexagon is also a bit more 
symmetrical and consistent as it is stopped down.

7.  The rear element of the Tokina is considerably larger and mounted 
into its cell differently than the Zuiko.

8.  The finish of the visible part of the mount is classic Oly matte on 
the Zuiko and shiny on the Tokina.

9.  The mechanisms that convey aperture setting to the pin on the rear 
and operate the diaphram from the other pin on the rear are quite 
different designs, with the Zuiko using the same basic design as in 
other Zuikos I've had apart.

10. The Zuiko has 16 elements in 12 groups and the Tokina has 16 in 13.

11. Ths Zuiko is styled pretty much like the 70-150 and 35-70/3.6 & 
35.-4.5 except fot the close-up ring, which isn't on those zooms, but it 
is in the same relative position as the zoom rings on those 2 touch 
models. I assume the otherwise odd design of the CU ring with the groove 
around the middle is to differentiate it from the zoom rings on the 
others. The Tokina is styled just like the other Tokina zooms I have. 
Finish of the body surfaces is very similar.

12. The nose of the Tokina in front of the zoom ring is much shorter 
than on the Zuiko, so the Oly hood doesn't clamp on as securely. The 
Tokina hood is also a clamp-on design but is calculated for use with a 
filter and uses something like an empty filter ring for the hood to 
clamp onto when a filter isn't. The Oly solution of a clamp on hood that 
doesn't interfere with filter use is much nicer.

My conclusion? It is extremely unlikely that the Zuiko is an adaptation 
of the Tokina. There are just too many differences that wouldn't make 
sense if it were, especially things like reversing and changing the 
length of travel of the CU helicoid, changing the pitch of the focusing 
helicoid and changing the internal design of the auto aperture 
mechanisms. It also really does appear to me from the reflections that 
the internal elements differ quite a bit in surface curvatures and/or 
locations."

Moose
-- 
_________________________________________________________________
Options: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/listinfo/olympus
Archives: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/private/olympus/
Themed Olympus Photo Exhibition: http://www.tope.nl/

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Sponsored by Tako
Impressum | Datenschutz